Opposition leader Angus Taylor will work through the Coalition’s final sticking points on a proposed east coast gas reserve in his negotiations with Labor after WA claimed it has won a key carve-out concession.
Mr Taylor had championed Western Australia’s bid to be excluded from the domestic reservation policy currently before the Senate alongside several other amendments.
Under the original legislation, the Federal Government sought to force exporters to reserve 20 per cent of gas for domestic use alongside a 10 per cent oversupply buffer, leaving it entirely to ministerial discretion as to whether WA’s obligation would be set to zero.
That broad discretionary power sparked alarm across WA’s resources sector.
Coalition has also sought limits on ministerial powers, a rule that will force a 110 per cent oversupply of the fuel and opposition to both a “must-sell” requirement for gas producers.
WA Premier Roger Cook had revealed on Wednesday morning he’d struck a deal with his federal counterparts to set the supply obligation from the State’s separate market “permanently” to zero.
He said the settings gave WA “an effective carve-out from the scheme, effectively shielding the State’s energy sector from Federal intervention.
“If passed by the Senate, this amendment would create a permanent carve-out for Western Australia from the Federal scheme,” Mr Cook said.
“Together, these settings will create an effective carve-out for WA.”
It came despite his federal Labor colleagues Madeleine King and Patrick Gorman repeatedly insisting a State carve-out would only raise “constitutional issues”.
Insiders said “firm views” were traded between Mr Cook and the Commonwealth but pushed back against calling it a messy exchange to reach a compromised stance.
But his WA Energy Minister Amber-Jade Sanderson brushed off questions on Wednesday about whether it was actually the carve-out they called for on an exaggerated concession.
“It was exactly what we were advocating for,” she said.
The Premier had previously expressed concerns about the ministerial discretion afforded to the Energy Minister which would require them to be satisfied before an exemption is granted.
Many concerned stakeholders argued that discretion, which remains in the bill, would give the Energy Minister an effective veto over key decisions.
“It’s still in the negotiation phase and hasn’t passed the Senate, and we’ll allow those negotiations. I’m not going to give an iterative commentary on them,” she said.
“It’s still underway. I haven’t seen the final fine print.
“I think it’s important that we allow those discussions to be undertaken.”
Industry sources said they remained cautiously optimistic the amendment creates an avenue for a permanent carve-out but said details of the exemption order - including when and if it could be revoked in future - would determine the degree of certainty it provides.
Australian Energy Producers described it as a “common-sense” step to recognise WA’s long-standing domestic gas policy - which was formalised in 2006.
“Industry has consistently called for WA to be excluded from the legislation to preserve the state’s well-functioning gas market and avoid unnecessary regulatory duplication,” they said in a statement.
“The same certainty should now be extended to Northern Territory LNG exporters, given the Territory’s limited connection to the east coast gas market.”
The Chamber of Minerals and Energy WA (CME) welcomed the amendment which would allow for the exemption for WA’s gas market to run indefinitely.
Under the amendments, a determination varying a market’s domestic supply obligation would apply until it is varied or revoked, rather than for a fixed term.
CME boss Aaron Morey said it was a key recommendation in their submission to the Senate inquiry, and in its evidence to the Senate Economics Legislation Committee in October.
“An exemption that doesn’t expire is good news for WA,” Mr Morey said.
“But nothing is certain until the decision is made.
“Until WA’s domestic supply obligation is formally set to zero, investors are being asked to back multi-billion-dollar projects on a promise.”
Mr Morey said it must also be made clear that the exemption covers future projects, not just those already operating.
Mr Taylor welcomed the clarification of WA’s role in the scheme on Wednesday but said he would review the new amendment to assess whether it was enough for his party across the line.
The Liberal leader had vowed to fight for a WA carve-out in his keynote address at the State’s Liberal party annual conference in Perth last month.
“I’ve said for a long time there needs to be a carve-out for WA,” he said.
“We’ve just seen a proposal come forward from the government. We’ll look at it.
“We welcome the fact that it’s clearly a step in the right direction but it has to genuinely carve-out Western Australia, because that’s not where the problem is.
“The problem is on the east coast right now, and we need a solution to that.”
Deputy Liberal leader Jane Hume welcomed the last-minute deal between WA and the federal government but insisted further assurances the scheme wouldn’t impact future investment was needed.
“We still need to make sure that any reservation scheme that is established doesn’t turn away new investment,” she tells News 24.
“There are ways to fix this. We do want to help the government get to a solution where we can have a gas reservation for domestic use, but we also don’t want to discourage new investment and export opportunities.”
Asia Natural Gas and Energy Association acting chief executive Stephanie Duran encouraged the Federal Government and the Coalition to work together to pass the WA carve-out but ensure it got “the rest of the scheme right”.
“Asian buyers and investors know Western Australia’s reservation system well,” he said.
“It has worked for nearly 20 years, with certainty and consistency of policy attracting investment that has delivered reliable, affordable gas to WA households and industry while also supplying long-term LNG partners across Asia.
“Keeping that system in place is a sensible, practical step.
“If the Senate passes the amendment, it would give certainty to about 60 per cent of Australia’s LNG exports and to the partners who have invested in them.
“At a national level, there is still work to do to make the DGRS fit for purpose. The ‘must sell’ and over-supply provisions and the ‘active steps’ obligation need further refinement, so the scheme does not discourage the investment in domestic production it is meant to support.”
Industry Minister Tim Ayres said he was confident the legislation would pass the Senate by this Thursday, with Labor racing to reach a deal before Parliament breaks for summer next week.
While the bill was listed for debate on Wednesday’s Senate notice paper, it is likely to be brought to a vote on Thursday.
Mr Cook has called on all West Australian senators across the political aisle to back the deal “and do the right thing for WA”.
WA’s most senior Liberal Senator Michaelia Cash issued a scathing hit to Ms King on social media over her rejection of the carve out.
She insisted Ms King deserved to lose her seat south of Perth at the next election if she wasn’t prepared to advocate for West Aussies on issues in Canberra.
“What a betrayal of Western Australia. It’s called standing up for Western Australia. If you can’t stand up for a system that works for WA, then quite frankly you deserve to lose your seat at the next election,” Senator Cash said.
One Nation leader Pauline Hanson, however, still won’t support the reserve but says she hasn’t been influenced by her donors.
Get the latest news from thewest.com.au in your inbox.
Sign up for our emails