HK cardinal criticises Vatican-China deal

Staff WritersReuters
Cardinal Joseph Zen has criticised the Vatican for an "unwise" deal with the Chinese government.
Camera IconCardinal Joseph Zen has criticised the Vatican for an "unwise" deal with the Chinese government. Credit: AP

Hong Kong's Cardinal Joseph Zen - in his first public remarks since he was arrested in a national security case earlier this month - has criticised the Vatican for its "unwise" deal with China that is due for renewal in September.

Zen, a 90-year-old retired Bishop of Hong Kong, is one of the most senior Catholics in Asia.

He spoke at a mass for the Chinese Catholic church almost two weeks after his arrest as part of a national security police probe into foreign collusion over a legal support fund.

Arrested with four other activists, Zen was released on police bail pending any possible formal charges.

The five, who also include singer Denise Ho and former opposition lawmakers Margaret Ng and Cyd Ho, were arrested two weeks ago on suspicion of collusion with foreign forces but were not charged at that time.

"The Vatican may have acted out of good faith but they have made an unwise decision," Zen told a gathering of 300 people at a small neighbourhood church on Hong Kong island.

He earlier prayed for "brothers and sisters who cannot attend the mass in any form tonight - for they have no freedom now".

Zen has long been a critic of the deal first struck in 2018 in a bid to ease a longstanding divide across mainland China between an underground flock loyal to the Vatican and a state-backed official church.

The deal, centred on co-operation over the appointment of bishops and whose details have never been made public, was extended in 2020 pending a renewal later this year.

Zen's appearance came hours after a brief court hearing where he pleaded not guilty to a minor related offence of failing to register the fund as a society with the police.

It is unclear if authorities plan to charge Zen and four others with additional national security offences at a later date.

Their trial is to begin on September 19 and take place over five days.

The White House and human rights groups have condemned the prospect of national security charges against Zen and other activists.

The Vatican has expressed "concern" and said it was following developments "with extreme attention".

Zen did not go into detail about his own situation but said it was normal for Catholics to "bear some pain".

with reporting from AP

Get the latest news from in your inbox.

Sign up for our emails